
In Loving Memory
Robert Matthews "The Prophet Matthias"
"Robert lived an extraordinary life defined by sweeping spiritual ambition, controversy, and profound social upheaval. Starting as an ordinary rural craftsman, Robert sought deeper meaning across numer…"
Life Story
Honoring Their Path
Robert lived an extraordinary life defined by sweeping spiritual ambition, controversy, and profound social upheaval. Starting as an ordinary rural craftsman, Robert sought deeper meaning across numerous theological movements during an era of intense religious transformation. Robert ultimately established a communal religious movement that drew ardent followers and captured widespread public fascination. Legal struggles and fierce public disputes eventually shattered the community Robert built. Robert spent later years wandering across the frontier, seeking renewed purpose while leaving a lasting mark on religious history. Robert passed away at approximately fifty-three years of age, leaving observers captivated and divided by a life of relentless spiritual conviction.
Life Chapters
The Chapters of Their Story
Faith & Religious Life
FreeRobert was raised inside the strict Anti-Burgher Secession Presbyterian church of upstate New York, a Scotch Calvinist body that held its people to hard rules and harder expectations. As he grew into manhood he was caught up in the fervent revivals of the Second Great Awakening, and for a time he moved toward Methodism before setting off on a theology entirely his own. Robert came to believe he was called to the ministry not by any board of churchmen but by overwhelming inward impressions of judgment about to fall. He said he had vivid dreams and visions, and in June 1830 he dreamed of a flood coming down on Albany as a sign of divine wrath. Rather than confirm his calling, the ministers around him turned it down and treated his revelations as a disruption. Robert read that rejection as permission to preach outside church walls altogether. He took the name Matthias, declaring that the spirit of the biblical apostle Matthias had come upon him to restore the primitive church. He told his disciples he spoke with God directly, and he performed solemn rites to purify believers for a coming thousand-year reign. He built a tightly ruled patriarchal kingdom in which daily life was set by ordinances revealed only through his own visions. His followers accepted the name "Prophet Matthias" because he handled scripture with startling fluency and explained the moral disorder of the age in dramatic terms. The press seized on the title because he carried an iron ruler and a ceremonial sword as visible emblems of judgment over an unrepentant nation. Robert eventually declared that the spirit of truth had entered an earthly messenger and that the Father's kingdom had arrived. He was, by his own account, "chief high-priest of the Jews, after the order of Melchisedeck," and he said plainly of himself, "I am God, there none else." Of the voice he believed spoke through him, he said, "My person is a trumpet whereby the spirit of truth speaks."
Final Years & Passing
FreeRobert left New York after the kingdom broke apart and after a jury cleared him of murder, and he went out through Pennsylvania, Ohio, and Missouri. In November 1835 he reached Kirtland, Ohio, calling himself "Joshua the Jewish Minister," and spent two days in long theological argument with the Latter Day Saint leader Joseph Smith. The two men traded views on resurrection and the passage of souls from father to son, and then parted badly, each deciding the other was possessed. Newspapers announced that the self-proclaimed prophet had turned Mormon, though he never joined, and one Ohio sheet ran the headline "Prophet Catch Prophet." Robert drifted on into the far Iowa Territory, away from the reporters and the crowds. He passed his last years in deep obscurity and thinning means, cut off from the men who had once funded him. No letters from that period survive in any number, and the record of his final months is made mostly of gaps. Those who had followed him had scattered back into ordinary lives, and the kingdom was by then a story rather than a place. He was remembered in Iowa as a bearded stranger who argued scripture with whoever would listen. He had once written from a cell, "I feel that the Lord is my stay," and had trusted that he would come out "like gold seven times refined" from "this fiery furnace," and he carried that same stubborn inward certainty into the west. He still claimed a remnant, and when boys trailed him down a street he turned and said, with something like good humor, "Why, I have a few followers yet!" Historical records place his death at about 1841, in humble circumstances, without the noise that had once followed him everywhere. No physician's account, death notice, or last word from the bedside has ever been located.
Childhood & Early Life
StandardAvailable with Standard membership
Academic & Education
StandardAvailable with Standard membership
Marriage & Family
StandardAvailable with Standard membership
Achievements & Career
StandardAvailable with Standard membership
Social & Community Life
StandardAvailable with Standard membership
Artistic & Creative Life
StandardAvailable with Standard membership
Ancestry & Heritage
PremiumAvailable with Premium membership
Political & Civic Life
PremiumAvailable with Premium membership
Trials & Resilience
PremiumAvailable with Premium membership
Private Life & Reflections
PremiumAvailable with Premium membership
Offspring & Legacy
PremiumAvailable with Premium membership
Funeral & Memorial Service
PremiumAvailable with Premium membership
Tributes & Remembrances
PremiumAvailable with Premium membership
Life story chaptersStandard+
Unlock all life chapters, the full photo gallery, ancestry tree, and more.
Share This Memorial
Help others find and honor Robert's memory.
Honor with a Keepsake
Looking for a tangible way to remember Robert? Always In Mind Gifts offers personalized keepsakes, jewelry, urns, and memorial décor — for people and beloved pets.
Browse Memorial Gifts →Tributes & Condolences
Honor Robert
Leave a tribute — a candle, a condolence, or a cherished memory.